Book review: The making of a Chief Justice of India by Sunita Singh

Disclaimer: Lengthy review!

I received this book through Amazon on the 4th of September. I began reading it, however, only on the 8th of September. It accompanied me to Chennai, where I was visiting my in-laws to celebrate Onam. If you’re wondering why the day is important, read on.

The author begins the book with the line, ‘ In 1926, India was 21 years away from Independence and George V was celebrating the birth of his grandchild, Elizabeth Alexandra Mary Windsor, who would later become Britain’s longest-serving monarch, Elizabeth II…Meanwhile on a cold winter day, in a dusty village of Northern India, a petite young woman was in the throes of labour, while her husband stood tense.’ It’s uncanny that the day I began reading the book, the 8th of September, was the day the Queen breathed her last and so did Justice KN Singh. A freak coincidence.

The foreword written by the author’s brother caught my attention. He uses the line,’ If you can walk with Kings-nor lose the common touch…’ from the poem, ‘IF’ by Rudyard Kipling, to describe his father. It came as a pleasant surprise as I have often felt the following lines from the same poem describe my father best- ‘If you can make one heap of all your winnings- And risk it on one turn of pitch-and-toss,-And lose, and start again at your beginnings-    And never breathe a word about your loss.’

The story

The book provides the history of India over a period of 87 years in a gist, that is easy to understand. The author weaves the story of KN Singh (CJI), with that of the country. So, what you get is an abridged version of not only the life of a man who held one of the highest positions in the country but, also the struggle for independence of the largest democracy in the world, in 1947 (in which the CJI played a small role, as a twenty-one-year-old and the aftermath of the struggle which includes the partition (India and Pakistan); China’s attack in 1962 and India’s retaliation; the split between Pakistan and Bangladesh in 1971 and India’s involvement which is coincidentally what I read on my flight to Dhaka.

Heroes of the freedom struggle, Nehru (India’s first PM), Gandhi (the Father of the nation- the man behind India’s non-violence movement), Rajendra Prasad (the first President of India, Lal Bahadur Shastri (India’s second PM, who died of a heart attack in Russia, the night on which he signed the Tashkent agreement, to end the war between India and Pakistan) that most Indians have read about, come to life in this book through the heartwarming stories the author shares, and had access to being the daughter of the CJI(KN Singh was an ardent supporter of the freedom movement in his youth and then went on to specialize in Election law and therefore was closely connected with these people). The author shares pictures from the family album of Vijaya Laxmi Pandit (Nehru’s sister) with CJI K.N. Singh and his wife, Krishna Kumari, the Justice and Pt. Nehru, Justice KN Singh playing golf, the justice taking oath as CJI and him in his chamber at the Supreme Court.

Some excerpts from the book

Before Shastri left for Kashmir, Nehru enquired from him, if he had a coat, to protect himself from the cold. Pandit Nehru was aware that Shastri was a simple person, who lived with just the bare necessities, so he got his own overcoat altered and gave him a cap too so that Shastri was sufficiently protected against the cold weather conditions in Kashmir.’

It is said that by the time she got married, Motilal Nehru had already become an active proponent of Swadeshi and wanted a simple wedding while her mother wanted a traditional Kashmiri one. Motilal Nehru was adamant that everyone should wear Khadi, including his daughter, the bride. However, khadi was rough cloth, not suitable for dying in pink, which was the traditional wedding colour for Kashmiri brides. But, then just a few days before the wedding, Vijaya Lakshmi received a very fine khadi saree, woven by Kasturba Gandhi, which could easily be dyed pink.’

Learnings from the book

Hard work and family time go hand in hand: KN Singh’s ability to work hard and yet make time for his family and friends stands out as an example to all. Anyone who reads the book will think twice before using ‘work,’ as an excuse for not being able to make time for those who matter.

A bird’s eye view of the legal system: enough to understand that being a judge is not child’s play. KN Singh’s story shows the journey one must take from being a student of law to reaching the highest position in the Indian legal system.

A peek into the history of India: The author makes a reference to significant political events that took place in India from1926 to 1987. It serves as a quick revision for those like me who tend to forget what happened first and what next. It brought back memories of things I’d heard my parents or family talk about. For instance, the milk shortage in India in the seventies – I remember my mother telling me how my dad would finish work and stand in a queue to collect milk from the store. He would go from store to store collecting milk as I, was apparently a very hungry baby. There’s another one I had heard about a three-year-old me going from door to door with my uncle showing my palm in the upright position (the symbol of Congress), asking for votes. This would be the election in which Indira Gandhi lost.

Another thing that stood out for me was Rajiv Gandhi’s achievements when he served as P.M. of India which I had forgotten. ‘ He reduced the voting age from 21 to 18 and brought about policies to modernize higher education and also set up Jawahar Navodaya Vidyalaya which provided free residential schools for classes six to twelve in rural areas. He also laid the foundation of the Panchayati Raj System aimed at taking democracy to the grassroots level. However, it was in the field of computers and telecommunications that a revolution occurred…It was during Rajiv’s time that MTNL was set up and Public Call Offices or PCOs in rural areas connected them to the world outside.’

Landmark cases

The author makes a reference to landmark judgements made by KN Singh and events that took place during the period of the book. Among these, the decisions taken regarding the death penalty in criminal cases and decisions taken to protect the environment for the future of the world, indicate the Chief Justice was a man who did not take decisions to solve a specific case, but, one who saw the bigger picture and solved the root problem. An example is the Ganga cleaning case in 1987. The author says, ‘ The judgement was a futuristic one, especially about asking schools to teach environmental education and awareness and directing the Central Government to get textbooks written for it and to distribute it to institutions free of cost so that children were taught the need for maintaining cleanliness both inside and outside the house. The bench also told the government to ensure that teachers were given the training to teach the subject.’
Kamal Narain Singh in his judgement said, ” We are conscious that closure of tanneries may bring unemployment, loss of revenue, but life, health and ecology have greater importance to the people, N.P.V.’

Language: Events that have shaped the history of the country and every Indian’s life are written with simplicity which is refreshing. It’s easy to understand and despite talking about truly important things, it is not a heavy read.

Who is the book for? It’s especially good for Indians who have not had an opportunity to study Indian History ( during British rule). While there’s only a passing mention of events and names of people who mattered, it’s a good place to start. You can always google and read more about the events and people. I found it was a good recap of the things I had forgotten and I have asked both my girls who have had an international education, to read it, so, they can better appreciate the country’s hard-earned freedom without feeling bogged down by too many details.
The book is also good for children who wish to study law. It will give them a peek into the world of law. The book is for anyone who is interested in learning about India’s journey from 1926 to 1987. It’s a quick read of 190 pages and should not take much time.

Review: five stars for the research done, for putting together so much information in 190 pages and making it a light read. The author, Sunita Singh, must be appreciated for this as it must be difficult to choose what to add and what not to when writing a book of this nature that covers decades. She has successfully done it without making the book textbook-like and yet providing just enough information to make the reader curious and hungry for more.

What the author says about the book

What goes into making a Chief Justice of India? Does a career in law suffice or does one need to understand the pulse of the nation, too?

The Making of a Chief Justice of IndiaLife and Times of Justice Kamal Narain Singh chronicles the story of a country in transition, fighting the British Raj, and creating new concepts of nationhood. Political upheavals, wars, new laws, and new governments all add to the intrigue.

Witness his journey from the corridors of the District Court of Allahabad to the highest seat of justice in the Supreme Court of India, presiding over some of the landmark judgements and controversial cases in the country.

What do others say?

An interesting and very readable biography.

– Padma Vibhushan Dr Karan Singh, Politician, Philanthropist, Philosopher, Writer

Chief Justice K.N. Singh’s is a legacy that merges the high traditions of Allahabad with the erudition of the Supreme Court of India. 

– Salman Khurshid, Senior Advocate Supreme Court, Politician, Eminent Author, Law Teacher

Buying the book: The print version of the book is available on Amazon for INR 499 by clicking on the link.

P.S. I hope the review gave you a fairly good idea of what to expect.

Copyright@smithavpennings.com. All Rights Reserved.

.

11 responses to “Book review: The making of a Chief Justice of India by Sunita Singh”

  1. robbiesinspiration Avatar

    HI Smitha, I am also a fan of IT although I am not a fan of Rudyard Kipling himself. Two great quotes for the poem. A most interesting review of this book. I don’t know much about Indian history although, of course, I do no Gandhi. This book certainly makes this history a lot more accessible.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Smitha V Avatar

      Hi Robbie, I remember reading your post somewhere of you liking ‘IF’ but not Rudyard Kipling. The book touches the surface of India History but it’s a great place to begin. You must read it, Robbie, since you enjoy reading History. It will give you a peek into the freedom struggle and beyond.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. robbiesinspiration Avatar

        HI Smitha, I have added it to my December reading list. I am glad to see you having a lovely time visiting old friends.

        Liked by 1 person

        1. Smitha V Avatar

          Hi Robbie…it was so amazing meeting everyone after 4 long years. Returning to Dhaka from Dubai was tougher than coming here from Mumbai.

          Liked by 1 person

  2. Sunita Singh Avatar
    Sunita Singh

    This is a lesson in writing a review. You amaze me with your writing skills!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Smitha V Avatar

      Thank you so much, dear Sunita. Love how you were able to pack so much information in 190 pages. That goes to show what a wonderful writer you are. Kudos on your book!

      Like

  3. rajkkhoja Avatar
    rajkkhoja

    Yes, very nice & simple words use and informative write in.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Smitha V Avatar

      Thank you for reading. Glad you enjoyed the review.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. rajkkhoja Avatar
        rajkkhoja

        You are most welcome!

        Liked by 1 person

  4. rajkkhoja Avatar
    rajkkhoja

    Very nice politics history write in. All over nice .

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Smitha V Avatar

      Thank you very much for taking the time to read the review. The book is simple and easy to read.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply. I love comments.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: